Steven Spielberg’s Lincoln is the kind of film that fully satisfies such lofty desires, and not because it’s a gassy, overwrought, sentimental spectacle with an obtrusive John Williams score. It’s actually none of those things, but rather a highly literate, and meticulously atmospheric portrait of a complex man and the rancorous political climate in which the final months of his presidency played out. More specifically, it's a terrific political thriller about Lincoln's quest to get the 13th amendment through Congress, thereby abolishing slavery in America forever before the Civil War ended and the returning Confederate states were able to overturn the Emancipation Proclamation. There's plenty of impassioned speechifying on the floor of Congress, with highly entertaining flourishes of 19th century rhetoric (screenwriter Tony Kushner adapted and embellished the actual words of the key Congressmen) and the incidental pleasures of playing Spot the Character Actor Behind that Facial Hair with James Spader, Michael Stuhlbarg, Hal Holbrook, Tim Blake Nelson, John Hawkes and Jackie Earle Haley in memorable supporting turns. Tommy Lee Jones probably has a Best Supporting Actor Oscar all tied up; his portrayal of radical abolitionist Thaddeus Stephens is shot through with the actor's own familiar gravitas and charisma.
But ultimately, of course, it's all about the man, Abraham Lincoln. That Daniel Day-Lewis is magnificent in the title role is not surprising in and of itself, yet I was unprepared for just how completely he rescues Lincoln from the folksy, railsplitting plaster sainthood of American legend. His Lincoln is equal parts prairie sage and shrewd political manipulator, impressively presidential and wearily melancholy in almost the same moment, exuding both integrity and vulnerability. It's a performance that manages both to affirm the legend of the man and allow us to peek behind the legend to see his sadness, his affection for his sons and his complicated feelings towards his difficult wife (Sally Field, who's effective but a good twenty years too old for the part.) In that respect, above all others, Lincoln feels like an exceptional achievement.




2 comments:
"It's actually none of those things, but rather a highly literate, and meticulously atmospheric portrait of a complex man and the rancorous political climate in which the final months of his presidency played out."
Indeed Pat, and you provide a splendid lead-in for this dense capsule assessment that I must second enthusiastically. In fact, by pulling back from the sentimental immersion that has won him some dissenters over the years, Spielberg has crafted one of the finest films of his career, and a film that 11 months into 2012 stands as the best American film of the year. It's interesting that a vociferous minority is complaining that teh film is didactic, when in fact these very same people have always complained that the iconic director has never failed to open the flood gates. By allowing Tony Kushner and the great Day-Lewis to take charge he has allowed this seminal event in U.S. history coverage from all angles, and there are even some political machinations here that are new even to the ardent Lincoln and Civil Wat buff. Abe is my favorite President and political figure, and it seems Day-Lewis has stepped into his skin to quote a line from Harper Lee's TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD in what immediately takes it's place among the most legendary performances of all time. While I don't doubt what you say about Field being 20 years too old, I must say you really do not notice it at all as he holds here age extraordinarily well, and she's absolutely luminous. Word out of Hollywood is that Lewis will win his third Oscar and Field could do the same thing as well, though LES MIZ' Anne Hathaway looms as her only competition. In any case LINCOLN is likely to win some of the film critics' awards groups as well in the coming weeks.
John Williams' score is lovely but more restrained than any other he's done, and it seems almost every artistic decision the director makes strikes gold. Pat, I know you had said at another blog that you were not thrilled with how Spielberg handled the assassination sequence, and may have even had issue with it being used at all. I must disagree on both points as it was extraordinarily tasteful to show the young boy's grief from another theatre, adn that Lincoln's life four month's from his death needed closure, something that Lee's surrendat and teh final deathbed scene achieved. There are a few bloggers out there who predictably are saying that 'Spielberg again doesn't know how to end a film.' Ha! These are people who haven't directed a single 10 second segment in their lives. The ending wa asbeautifully wrought, and what better finale than have Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address? No, he got it right, and he has contirbuted to the Lincoln literature mightily with an epic film where he connects the intellectual and the emotional in a film of quiet power, anchored by one of those rare performances when the lead actors becomes the character being played.
Sam -
Thanks for the kind words, and I agree with you that LINCOLN is one of Spielberg's very best films. (For the record, I'm not a Spielberg basher at all, but he does have the sentimental excess going on from time to time - not here thankfully.) I, too, loved the restrained and evocative John Williams score. I can't say that I found Sally Field luminous myself. She was fine, but while she doesn't look every one of her 66 years, she did look too old to be the mother of a 12 year old boy - and she did seem older than Abe, when in fact Mary was 10 years his junior - and that overshadowed her performance somewhat, for me.
As for the ending, I'm going to relent a little bit. I actually DO very much like that the film concludes with an excerpt from Lincoln's second inaugural address and I also respect the decision NOT to show the actual assassination at Ford's Theater. But the scene with Tad at the theater learning of his father's death felt jarring to me and not in the right way - it felt exploitative of a child's grief, and combined with the perfunctory deathbed scene didn't have the impact on me that it obviously did on other viewers (like the loudly sobbing woman in our audience.) But those are VERY minor criticisms of what it truly a great American film
Post a Comment